| Year | Winner | Runners-up |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Argentina | Colombia |
| 2021 | Argentina | Brazil |
| 2019 | Brasil | Peru |
| 2016 | Chile | Argentina |
| 2015 | Chile | Argentina |
| 2011 | Uruguay | Paraguay |
| 2007 | Brasil | Argentina |
| 2004 | Brasil | Argentina |
| 2001 | Colombia | Mexico |
| 1999 | Brasil | Uruguay |
| 1997 | Brasil | Bolivia |
| 1995 | Uruguay | Brasil |
| 1993 | Argentina | Mexico |
| 1991 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1989 | Brasil | Uruguay |
| 1987 | Uruguay | Chile |
| 1983 | Uruguay | Brasil |
| 1979 | Paraguay | Chile |
| 1975 | Peru | Colombia |
| 1967 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1963 | Bolivia | Paraguay |
| 1959 [II] | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1959 [I] | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1957 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1956 | Uruguay | Chile |
| 1955 | Argentina | Chile |
| 1953 | Paraguay | Brasil |
| 1949 | Brasil | Paraguay |
| 1947 | Argentina | Paraguay |
| 1946 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1945 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1942 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1941 | Argentina | Uruguay |
| 1939 | Peru | Uruguay |
| 1937 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1935 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1929 | Argentina | Paraguay |
| 1927 | Argentina | Uruguay |
| 1926 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1925 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1924 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1923 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1922 | Brasil | Paraguay |
| 1921 | Argentina | Brasil |
| 1920 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1919 | Brasil | Uruguay |
| 1917 | Uruguay | Argentina |
| 1916 | Uruguay | Argentina |
